An environmental indemnity is a stand-alone agreement in which the borrower and its sponsors, jointly and severally, indemnify the lender and later holders of the loan for environmental losses at the property. It is full recourse even on a non-recourse loan and survives repayment.
The longer version
Who signs. The indemnitors are the borrowing entity and one or more creditworthy sponsors, signing jointly and severally. A 2011 CMBS loan's environmental indemnity filed with the SEC is typical: the borrower and two sponsor entities sign together as "Indemnitor" in favor of the lender. The protected group is wider than the lender of record. The "Indemnified Parties" in that form include anyone involved in originating or servicing the loan, anyone who holds or later acquires an interest in it, trustees and custodians, and anyone who takes the property after a foreclosure or deed in lieu.
Why lenders want it: CERCLA. Under section 107 of CERCLA the current owner or operator of a contaminated property is a liable party, whether or not it caused the contamination. A lender that only holds a mortgage is protected by the secured creditor exemption in section 101(20), as long as it does not participate in management of the facility. EPA's guidance says the exemption also survives foreclosure if the lender takes reasonable steps to sell the property at the earliest practicable, commercially reasonable time, on commercially reasonable terms. The exemption keeps the lender out of Superfund liability. It does nothing about cleanup costs that destroy the collateral's value, third-party claims, or the cost of the lender's own consultants, and that is what the indemnity pays for.
Scope. "Environmental Laws" is defined broadly. The filed form lists CERCLA, RCRA including the underground storage tank rules, the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, the Toxic Substances Control Act, the Safe Drinking Water Act and their state and local counterparts. "Losses" covers damages, fines, remediation costs and the fees of attorneys, engineers and environmental consultants. Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide, section 504.03, tells lenders to consider revising its Environmental Indemnity Agreement (Form 6085) so that any REC or CREC found in diligence is named specifically in the indemnity, with covenants to carry out the remediation plan and comply with any activity and use limitations.
Full recourse and survival. The indemnity is drafted as an exception to the loan's non-recourse and exculpation provisions, and the indemnitor is personally liable for it. In the filed form it can be enforced without first foreclosing or exhausting other collateral, without an Event of Default, and without a cap at the loan balance, and its obligations survive payment in full. Many loans also list environmental losses among the non-recourse carve-outs in the guaranty. The indemnity is the separate document built to outlast the loan.
What borrowers negotiate. The usual points are an exclusion for contamination that first occurs after the borrower loses possession through the lender's remedies (the filed form includes one), an end date some period after repayment, knowledge and materiality qualifiers on the covenants, and whether contamination caused by a third party is also a loan default. The Chicago firm Masuda Funai's view is that in the third-party case the indemnity should be triggered but the borrower should not be in default, provided it used commercially reasonable efforts to prevent the release and remediates as the loan documents require.
Sample clause outline, in the order the filed form uses. 1. Representations and warranties, incorporated from the loan agreement. 2. Environmental covenants: compliance with Environmental Laws, no releases, remediation starting within 30 days of notice. 3. Indemnification of the Indemnified Parties for Losses. 4. Exclusion for conditions first arising after the lender's remedies end the borrower's possession. 5. Duty to defend and payment of fees. 6. Definitions: Environmental Laws, Hazardous Substances, Indemnified Parties, Losses, Release, Remediation. 7. Unimpaired liability despite amendments to the loan. 8. Enforcement without exhausting collateral, and full recourse. 9. Survival past repayment. Then interest on unpaid amounts, waivers of defenses, and notice of legal actions within 10 business days.
The Phase I and, where needed, the Phase II environmental site assessment are what give the indemnity its specific content. A clean report keeps it a standard form. A recognized environmental condition turns it into a negotiated document with named conditions, a remediation plan and escrow or insurance requirements, and those items then belong on the closing checklist with an owner and a due date.
Common questions
- Who signs an environmental indemnity?
- The borrower and the same creditworthy sponsors who sign the carve-out guaranty, jointly and severally, since an indemnity from a single purpose entity with no other assets is of little use.
- Why is the environmental indemnity a separate document?
- So it can be full recourse and survive events that end the loan. Folded into the loan agreement it would be subject to the non-recourse provisions and released on repayment.
- Does an environmental indemnity survive repayment and foreclosure?
- Usually yes. Standard forms state that the obligations survive payment in full, and protect later holders and anyone who takes the property through foreclosure or a deed in lieu.
- If CERCLA has a secured creditor exemption, why does the lender need an indemnity?
- The exemption protects a lender that does not manage the property from owner or operator liability. It does not cover the lost collateral value, cleanup costs, third-party claims or the lender's own consultants, which the indemnity does.
- How does the environmental indemnity relate to the non-recourse carve-outs?
- Environmental losses often appear in the carve-out list as well. The indemnity is the stand-alone document with a broader definition of losses, enforcement without an Event of Default and survival after the loan is repaid.
- The Commercial Loan Documentation GuideWhere the indemnity sits.
- Commercial Real Estate Due Diligence ChecklistThe reports behind it.
- The commercial loan closing checklistSignature deliverables.
- Due diligence softwareThe request list, the owners and the dates in one place.
- Phase II environmental site assessmentThe test that sizes the risk.
- Non-recourse carve-outThe guaranty the indemnity sits beside.