
The short answer
In bank lending, an appraisal and an evaluation are two different regulatory products. An appraisal is a written opinion of market value prepared by a state licensed or certified appraiser under the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). An evaluation is a market value estimate that federal rules allow in place of an appraisal for certain exempt transactions. It does not have to be prepared by a licensed appraiser or follow USPAP, but it must be consistent with safe and sound banking practices and support the credit decision.
For commercial real estate at banks regulated by the OCC, FDIC and Federal Reserve, the dividing line is a transaction value of $500,000: above it, a state certified appraiser is required; at or below it, an evaluation is allowed. Business loans of $1 million or less that do not depend on real estate sale or rental income for repayment can also use an evaluation. Credit unions follow NCUA rules, where the line is $1,000,000 and the substitute is called a written estimate of market value.
How does an evaluation differ from an appraisal?
The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines (December 2010, 75 FR 77450) and the agencies' March 2016 advisory on evaluations set out most of the differences.
| Point | Appraisal | Evaluation |
|---|---|---|
| Who performs it | A state licensed or certified appraiser; certified above $500,000 for commercial real estate | A knowledgeable, competent person independent of the transaction and of loan production; a bank employee or a third party |
| Standard | Must conform to USPAP and the agencies' minimum appraisal standards | No USPAP requirement; must be consistent with safe and sound banking practices |
| When required | Any real estate-related financial transaction unless an exemption applies | Transactions exempt under the commercial threshold, the business loan exemption, certain existing extensions of credit and the residential threshold |
| Format | A USPAP report option; restricted reports are generally not appropriate for underwriting | No standard format; content must let a reader understand the analysis |
| Content | Market value as defined in the regulation, scope of work, approaches, deductions and discounts, USPAP certification | Location, description, market value in actual condition, inspection method, analysis, sources, preparer |
| Engagement | Engaged directly by the institution or its agent | Preparer selected and engaged directly by the institution or its agent |
| Review | Reviewed before the credit decision, including for USPAP compliance | Reviewed before the credit decision for support and policy compliance |
What is the appraisal threshold for commercial real estate?
$500,000 for banks. The OCC (12 CFR 34.43), the FDIC (12 CFR 323.3) and the Federal Reserve (12 CFR 225.63) each exempt commercial real estate transactions with a transaction value of $500,000 or less from the appraisal requirement, and each requires a state certified appraiser above that amount. The three agencies raised the threshold from $250,000, a level set in 1994, in a final rule announced on April 2, 2018. They had proposed $400,000. The same sections set a separate residential threshold of $400,000, which applies to 1-to-4 family collateral, not to commercial property.
Transaction value generally means the loan amount, as the 2016 advisory notes, so the test runs on the loan and not on the property's price. The advisory itself still quotes the pre-2018 $250,000 line, so read the number from the current CFR text. An exempt transaction is not a valuation-free transaction: section 34.43(b) and its FDIC and Federal Reserve counterparts require an appropriate evaluation of the real property collateral, consistent with safe and sound banking practices.
| Lender | Rule | Appraisal required | Below the line |
|---|---|---|---|
| National banks and federal savings associations | 12 CFR 34.43 (OCC) | Commercial real estate above $500,000, state certified appraiser | Appropriate evaluation |
| State nonmember banks | 12 CFR 323.3 (FDIC) | Commercial real estate above $500,000, state certified appraiser | Appropriate evaluation |
| State member banks and bank holding companies | 12 CFR 225.63 (Federal Reserve) | Commercial real estate above $500,000, state certified appraiser | Appropriate evaluation |
| Any of the above, business loans | Same sections, business loan exemption | Above $1 million, or when repayment depends primarily on real estate sale or rents | Appropriate evaluation |
| Federally insured credit unions | 12 CFR 722.103 (NCUA) | $1,000,000 or more, state certified appraiser | Written estimate of market value |
When does the $1 million business loan exemption apply?
The business loan exemption covers a loan with a transaction value of $1 million or less when the sale of, or rental income from, real estate is not the primary source of repayment. The typical case is an operating company borrowing against the building it occupies, where cash flow from the business repays the loan. This exemption is what allows one of the owner-occupied commercial real estate loans between $500,000 and $1 million to close on an evaluation.
The 2010 Guidelines expect the institution to determine that the primary source of repayment is operating cash flow from the business rather than rental income or the sale of real estate. A loan to an investor whose tenants pay the debt service does not qualify for this exemption; above $500,000 it needs an appraisal.
What appraisal thresholds apply to credit unions?
NCUA writes its own rule. Under 12 CFR 722.103, a state certified appraiser is required for a transaction value of $1,000,000 or more. NCUA raised its commercial threshold from $250,000 to $1,000,000 in a final rule published July 24, 2019 and effective October 22, 2019. That rule treats as commercial any transaction not secured by a single 1-to-4 family residential property, so multifamily of five or more units falls on the commercial side. The 2019 rule left the residential threshold at $250,000; a separate NCUA final rule effective April 30, 2020 (85 FR 23909) raised it to $400,000.
Below the threshold, NCUA requires a written estimate of market value, prepared by someone independent of loan production and collection, with no direct, indirect or prospective interest in the property or transaction, and qualified for the type and amount of credit. NCUA joined the 2010 Guidelines but was not a party to the 2016 advisory, and the Guidelines note that NCUA's rule has no appraisal exemption specific to member business loans. Credit union lending teams that also follow bank practice should keep the two rule sets apart in policy, and the member business loan file should show which one the valuation met.
Who can perform an evaluation?
Under the 2016 advisory, the preparer should be knowledgeable, competent and independent of the transaction and of the institution's loan production function. A bank employee or a third party can do it, and in smaller communities bankers and third-party real estate professionals may be qualified.
The Guidelines list appraisers, real estate lending professionals, agricultural extension agents and foresters as possible preparers. An institution may use a licensed appraiser for an evaluation, and the Guidelines point to USPAP Advisory Opinion 13 for how an appraiser handles that work. Either way the appraiser's role and the evaluator's share one rule: the institution or its agent selects and engages them, independence is compromised when a borrower recommends the person, and loan production staff should not pick the preparer for a specific deal.
What must an evaluation contain?
There is no standard form. The Guidelines set a minimum instead, and the advisory adds that the content should let a reader understand the analysis behind the value conclusion and the decision to make the loan. At a minimum, the evaluation should:
- Identify the propertyIts location, a description, and its current and projected use.
- State a market valueIn the property's actual physical condition, use and zoning as of the effective date, which is the date the analysis was completed, with any limiting conditions.
- Explain how condition was confirmedThe method used and the extent of any inspection. Assuming average condition without support is not acceptable.
- Describe the analysisThe approach used and the supporting information, including any supplemental information when an analytical tool was used.
- Cite the sourcesMarket sales databases, tax and land records, prior sales of the subject, comparable sales, inspection evidence, photos, neighborhood and local market conditions, as applicable.
- Name the preparerName, contact information and signature when a person prepared it.
Can an AVM or broker opinion be an evaluation?
An automated valuation model can support an evaluation but is not one on its own. The Guidelines say an AVM result, by itself or signed by an appraiser, is not an appraisal, and that an institution may not rely solely on an AVM for an evaluation unless the result meets the evaluation standards, including the property's actual physical condition. A tax assessment value is treated the same way. Both need validation and policy before use.
A broker price opinion cannot be used as an evaluation, because it provides a sales or list price rather than market value. Neither can a competitive market analysis. Both may feed into an evaluation. The interagency AVM quality control rule effective October 1, 2025 applies to AVMs used for mortgages secured by a consumer's principal dwelling, so it does not reach a commercial evaluation; the 2010 Guidelines still govern there.
When should a lender order an appraisal anyway?
An exemption permits an evaluation. It does not require one. The Guidelines ask for a policy on when to appraise below the threshold and name higher risk cases: combined loan-to-value above the supervisory limits, atypical properties, properties outside the institution's usual market, existing credits with significant risk, and borrowers with high risk characteristics. The 2016 advisory adds that an appraisal may be a prerequisite for some secondary market transactions.
Leverage is where the choice shows. Under the interagency real estate lending standards, value for an acquisition loan is the lesser of the actual acquisition cost or the appraised or evaluated value, and improved property carries a supervisory limit of 85 percent. Running both numbers through an LTV calculator before the valuation is ordered tells the credit team whether the loan sits near a limit. A lender's commercial real estate due diligence checklist should record which valuation type was chosen and why.
How long is an evaluation or appraisal valid?
Neither has a fixed shelf life in the rules. The Guidelines allow an existing appraisal or evaluation to support a later transaction if the institution's criteria show it still reflects market value, and the file documents that conclusion. A new valuation is needed when value has changed because of factors such as passage of time, local market volatility, financing conditions, natural disasters, supply of competing properties, improvements or lack of maintenance, changes in cap rates and lease terms, zoning changes or environmental contamination.
Disaster areas have a separate path. On April 18, 2025 the OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC and NCUA published an order granting temporary exceptions from appraisal requirements for properties in Los Angeles County affected by the January 2025 wildfires, for binding commitments made through January 8, 2028. The institution must still determine that the property's value supports the decision to lend.
What should the valuation file show an examiner?
Sequence and independence. The Guidelines expect the appraisal or evaluation to be reviewed before the final credit decision, by someone independent of the transaction and insulated from loan production, with a depth of review that matches the risk. Development work should not start before the institution has engaged the preparer, and the engagement letter belongs in the credit file. Review method is covered in reading a commercial appraisal, and fees and timing in commercial appraisal cost.
An examiner reading the file should be able to see which rule applied, which valuation type was used, who prepared it, who reviewed it and when. A bank that orders valuations in its loan origination system and closes the loan in a separate workspace has to keep those dates consistent across both, the system boundary the Prodeal vs nCino comparison describes.
Questions lenders ask
- Does an evaluation have to follow USPAP?
- No. The 2016 interagency advisory says an evaluation is not required to be completed by a state licensed or certified appraiser or to comply with USPAP. It must be consistent with safe and sound banking practices and the 2010 Guidelines.
- Are bank appraisals accurate?
- Accuracy rests on independence and review. Federal rules require the bank or its agent to engage the appraiser directly, and the Guidelines require review before the credit decision. A reviewer cannot change the value, but a USPAP appraisal review by a qualified appraiser can give a second opinion of value the institution may rely on.
- What is a red flag on a commercial appraisal or evaluation?
- Unsupported assumptions, such as average condition with no inspection, a value premise that does not match the loan, missing deductions for partially leased or proposed property, a borrower-ordered report, or any sign that a target value was communicated to the preparer.
- What happens if the appraisal is higher than the purchase price?
- For an acquisition loan, the interagency lending standards define value as the lesser of the actual acquisition cost or the estimated value. A higher appraisal does not raise the value used for supervisory loan-to-value.
- Can a borrower give the bank its own appraisal?
- A borrower-ordered or borrower-provided appraisal violates the agencies' appraisal rules. A borrower can tell the bank that a current appraisal exists, and the bank may request it directly from the financial institution that engaged the appraiser.
- How is a commercial appraisal value reached?
- The 2016 advisory names the three approaches the valuation profession uses: sales comparison, cost and income. The approach should fit the property; the advisory points to the income approach for income-producing property and the cost approach particularly for newer construction.
Sources and further reading
- OCC, FDIC, Federal Reserve, NCUA, OTS, Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, 75 FR 77450, December 10, 2010
- Federal Reserve, FDIC, OCC, Interagency Advisory on Use of Evaluations in Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, March 4, 2016 (FDIC FIL-16-2016 attachment)
- Federal Reserve, SR 16-5, March 4, 2016
- eCFR, 12 CFR 34.43, Appraisals required (OCC), read 2026-11-06
- eCFR, 12 CFR 34.45, Appraiser independence (OCC), read 2026-11-06
- eCFR, 12 CFR 34.44, Minimum appraisal standards (OCC), read 2026-11-06
- eCFR, 12 CFR 323.3, Appraisals required (FDIC), read 2026-11-06
- eCFR, 12 CFR 225.63, Appraisals required (Federal Reserve), read 2026-11-06
- eCFR, 12 CFR 722.103, Appraisals and written estimates of market value requirements (NCUA), read 2026-11-06
- NCUA, Real Estate Appraisals final rule, 84 FR 35525, July 24, 2019
- NCUA, Real Estate Appraisals final rule (residential threshold to $400,000), 85 FR 23909, April 30, 2020
- Federal Reserve, FDIC, OCC, press release on raising the commercial real estate appraisal threshold to $500,000, April 2, 2018
- eCFR, Appendix A to Subpart D of 12 CFR Part 34, Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate Lending Policies, read 2026-11-06
- OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC, NCUA, Statement and order, temporary exceptions to appraisal requirements, 90 FR, April 18, 2025
- OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC, NCUA, CFPB, FHFA, Quality Control Standards for Automated Valuation Models, 89 FR 64538, August 7, 2024

Patrick Janson leads enterprise sales and solution strategy at Prodeal. He served as Prodeal's Chief Operating Officer from 2017 to 2022 and returned in 2024 following his time as a Product Lead in Hines' Innovation Group. He brings more than 15 years of experience in commercial real estate finance and technology, having started his career in commercial real estate lending at Emerald Creek Capital. Patrick serves on the Mortgage Bankers Association's Technology Advisory Council, is a former Chairman of the Young Mortgage Bankers Association, and has been a guest speaker at Cornell and Columbia Universities.
- Commercial real estate due diligence checklistWhere the valuation sits among the third-party reports.
- AppraisalThe definition.
- LTV calculatorTest leverage against the lesser of cost or value.
- How do lenders review a commercial appraisal?Reading the report once it arrives.
- Commercial appraisal cost and turnaroundWhat drives the fee and the timeline.
- Credit union business lendingHow NCUA rules shape commercial lending at credit unions.