
The short answer
CAMELS is the rating system NCUA examiners use to score the condition of a federally insured credit union: Capital adequacy, Asset quality, Management, Earnings, Liquidity risk and Sensitivity to market risk. Each component and the composite are rated 1 to 5, where 1 is strongest and 5 weakest. NCUA added the S in a final rule published October 27, 2021, for examinations starting on or after April 1, 2022.
A commercial real estate book shows up mostly in Asset quality and Management: underwriting, rating accuracy, concentrations, problem loans and board oversight. Ratings are part of the confidential examination record. An FFIEC proposal of May 2026 would revise the definitions; comments closed August 17, 2026, and no final action had been published when this post was checked on November 6, 2026.
What is the NCUA CAMELS rating system?
NCUA's Examiner's Guide describes CAMELS as a rating meant to reflect all significant financial, operational and management factors examiners assess. NCUA assigns the ratings at the conclusion of the examination, including an assessment of the level and direction of risk. The NCUA exam is where that evidence is collected, and the NCUA Examiner's Guide is the manual examiners use.
22-CU-05 Appendix A sets three principles. Each credit union is rated on its own condition, not against peer averages. Examiners weigh qualitative as well as quantitative factors, because numbers often lag. And they assess risk exposure by category (credit, interest rate, liquidity, transaction, compliance and strategic) and decide how each affects the components. Ratings also drive supervision: the Guide says lower rated credit unions receive more supervision hours.
When did NCUA change CAMEL to CAMELS?
The bank regulators rated market risk separately long before NCUA did. The FFIEC adopted the Uniform Financial Institutions Rating System in 1979 and added a sixth component, sensitivity to market risk, in its December 1996 revision. NCUA kept CAMEL, with market risk folded into an L component for liquidity and asset liability management.
The final rule, 86 FR 59282 (October 27, 2021), added S and redefined L as liquidity risk, so the two could be told apart and credit union ratings would line up with the other agencies. Letter to Credit Unions 22-CU-05 (March 2022) carries the revised definitions in Appendix A and says the Capital, Asset quality, Management and Earnings criteria and the composite did not change.
NCUA, CAMELS Rating System final rule, 86 FR 59282, October 27, 2021; Letter to Credit Unions 22-CU-05, March 2022
What does each CAMELS component measure?
Appendix A to 22-CU-05 lists the evaluation factors for each component. The second column summarizes them. The third column is editorial: it maps those factors to the parts of a commercial real estate program they touch, and it is not NCUA text.
| Component | What NCUA rates | Where CRE lending shows up (editorial) |
|---|---|---|
| C: Capital adequacy | Capital level and quality relative to risk and management's ability to control it | Loan and investment concentrations, classified assets, growth plans and the risk of new business lines |
| A: Asset quality | Existing and potential credit risk in loans, investments, other real estate owned and off-balance-sheet items, plus the allowance | Underwriting quality, controls over high concentrations and new programs, classified and nonaccrual loans, timely identification of problem loans |
| M: Management | The board's and management's ability to identify, measure, monitor and control risk and to comply with law | Board-approved lending policy, risk measurement and monitoring, responsiveness to exam and audit findings, products suited to staff experience |
| E: Earnings | Whether current and future earnings can fund capital and allowances given the risk profile | Credit losses, provisions and the quality and sources of loan income |
| L: Liquidity risk | Liquidity sources against funding needs and the quality of liquidity risk management | Reliance on short-term, volatile funds to carry longer-term assets such as CRE term loans |
| S: Sensitivity to market risk | Exposure of earnings and economic value of capital to changes in interest rates and market prices | Rate and repricing structure of the CRE book and how it fits interest rate risk limits |
How does the 1 to 5 CAMELS scale work?
A 1 is the highest rating and the least supervisory concern; a 5 is the lowest and the most. The composite should normally resemble the components, but Appendix A says it is not derived solely by averaging them, and the current text gives Management special consideration.
The table follows 22-CU-05 Appendix A, the letter that carries the criteria. NCUA's two current texts differ on thresholds: Appendix A says a composite 2 generally has no component rated 3, 4 or 5, and a composite 3 generally none rated 4 or 5. The Examiner's Guide composite page (updated April 29, 2022) says no 4 or 5 for a 2 and no 5 for a 3.
| Composite | Condition | Supervisory response |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sound in every respect; components generally rated 1 or 2; weaknesses minor | No supervisory concern |
| 2 | Fundamentally sound; generally no component rated 3, 4 or 5; only moderate weaknesses, well within management's capacity to correct | Informal and limited |
| 3 | Some supervisory concern in one or more components; weaknesses moderate to severe | More than normal supervision, possibly enforcement; failure appears unlikely |
| 4 | Unsafe and unsound practices; serious deficiencies not being addressed satisfactorily | Close supervisory attention; enforcement in most cases; failure a distinct possibility if not resolved |
| 5 | Extremely unsafe and unsound practices; critically deficient performance | Immediate outside assistance needed; failure highly probable |
How does CRE lending affect the Asset quality rating?
Asset quality is where a commercial real estate book is read loan by loan. The Appendix A factors that matter most for CRE are underwriting quality, due diligence on new programs and high concentrations, classified, nonaccrual and restructured loans, timely identification of problem assets, and concentrations that present undue risk.
NCUA's commercial lending rule, 12 CFR 723.4(g), sets the baseline: a credit risk rating system with ratings assigned at inception and reviewed as often as risk monitoring requires, plus periodic loan review that reevaluates collateral value and marketability. The credit union business lending post covers Part 723 and the member business loan cap.
In the file, examiners check whether the rating still matches the loan. The Examiner's Guide page on credit risk rating systems says loans should generally be formally reviewed once a year, when year-end financial statements arrive, with large, new, higher risk, problem and complex loans reviewed more often. A reviewer who recomputes coverage from the latest operating statement with a debt service coverage ratio calculation and finds it well below the approval figure will ask why the rating did not move.
Workouts are read the same way. The June 2023 interagency Policy Statement on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Accommodations and Workouts, which NCUA joined, superseded the 2009 workout guidance and gives examples of how to classify and account for loans affected by workout activity.
How does CRE lending show up in the Management rating?
Management is rated on whether the board and senior staff can identify, measure, monitor and control risk. The Appendix A factors closest to a commercial program are written, board-approved policies that are followed; effective risk measurement and monitoring; responsiveness to examination and audit findings; products suited to the credit union's size and management experience; and succession planning for key positions.
Much of the evidence sits in documents: a credit memo that supports the risk rating, exception reports that reach the board, and an independent commercial loan review function. The Examiner's Guide says the in-depth assessment of risk should be performed by independent loan review, and that examiners validate ratings on a sample of loans rather than underwriting each one.
Where that evidence lives matters too. Many credit unions decide credit in a loan origination system and assemble the closing file somewhere else, and the Prodeal vs nCino comparison covers that split between origination software and the closing workspace.
Do Earnings, Liquidity and S matter for CRE lenders?
Yes, though less directly. On Earnings, NCUA Supervisory Letter 06-01, Evaluating Earnings, notes that the CAMEL matrix of 1987 tied a 1 percent return on average assets to an Earnings 1, and that ratings are not automatically determined by matrix ratios. Earnings are judged against the credit union's net worth needs and risks.
On Liquidity, one factor is the degree of reliance on short-term, volatile funds to fund longer-term assets, the funding question a growing term loan book raises. On S, examiners look at how earnings and the economic value of capital respond to rate changes, management's ability to control market risk, and the complexity of the exposure. The rate and repricing terms of commercial loans feed both.
Where is CAMELS in the NCUA Examiner's Guide?
The Guide has a CAMELS Ratings chapter, and the component criteria sit in 22-CU-05 Appendix A, which the Guide links to. The NCUA exam preparation guide covers the quarter before an exam; these are the pages behind the ratings.
- CAMELS Ratings introductionPurpose, the six components and how ratings are assigned. Updated April 29, 2022.
- Composite RatingThe 1 to 5 composite definitions and the link between ratings and supervision hours.
- Assigning a CAMELS Rating to the S ComponentPoints examiners to the S criteria in Appendix A. Updated December 6, 2024.
- Credit Risk Rating SystemsIn the commercial lending chapter: how ratings are designed, reviewed and validated.
Are CAMELS ratings confidential?
Yes. NCUA's records rule, 12 CFR 792.30, bars officers, employees and agents of NCUA or of any federally insured credit union from disclosing exempt NCUA records except to those entitled to them for official duties, or as the rule provides. Under 792.31, examination reports NCUA shares remain its property and may not be disclosed without NCUA's express written authorization.
NCUA's Office of General Counsel concluded in Opinion 97-0951 (December 1997) that a credit union's CAMEL rating is part of the NCUA examination, so the credit union is also barred from disclosing it. A credit union that disagrees with its rating has a formal route: 22-CU-05 notes that composite ratings of 3, 4 or 5, and in some circumstances a component rating, can be appealed under 12 CFR Part 746, subpart A.
What would the 2026 FFIEC CAMELS proposal change?
On May 19, 2026 the FFIEC published a request for comment on revisions to the Uniform Financial Institutions Rating System, 91 FR 29128. It keeps the six components and the 1 to 5 scale and aims to focus ratings on material financial risk. NCUA's section of the notice says the recommendation would apply to all federally insured credit unions, including state-chartered ones. If adopted, the agencies would have to implement it. Comments closed August 17, 2026, and a Federal Register search on November 6, 2026 found no final FFIEC action.
- Management loses its special weightThe direction to give Management special consideration in the composite would be removed.
- A higher bar for a Management 3Ratings of 3 or worse would generally require practices that result in material financial risk, or unreliable financial or regulatory reporting.
- Fewer Management factorsManagement depth and succession, responsiveness to auditors and supervisors, and serving community needs would be dropped.
- Composite tied to financial riskWeaknesses with no observable deterioration in financial condition would not alone support a composite 4 or worse.
- Asset quality wordingAllowance for loan and lease losses becomes allowances for credit losses. Concentrations remain a factor; CRE is not singled out.
- Reputation risk removedAll references to reputation risk come out of the rating system.
Questions lenders ask
- Is the CAMELS composite an average of the components?
- No. Appendix A says the composite should normally resemble the components but is not derived solely by an arithmetic average. Examiners weigh how the components interact.
- Is a CAMELS 3 rating bad?
- It signals some supervisory concern: weaknesses from moderate to severe in one or more components and more than normal supervision, possibly enforcement, though failure appears unlikely (22-CU-05 Appendix A).
- Who is allowed to see a credit union's CAMELS ratings?
- Under 12 CFR 792.30 and 792.31, exempt records and examination reports remain NCUA's property and may not be disclosed without NCUA's express written authorization, except as the rule provides. NCUA's General Counsel has said a credit union's rating is part of the examination and the credit union may not disclose it.
- How does an NCUA rating appeal work?
- 22-CU-05 says a credit union may formally appeal a composite rating of 3, 4 or 5, and in some circumstances a component rating, under the procedures in 12 CFR Part 746, subpart A.
- Does a 1 percent ROA earn an Earnings rating of 1?
- Not automatically. Supervisory Letter 06-01 says the 1987 CAMEL matrix tied a 1 percent ROA to an Earnings 1, but ratings are not set by matrix ratios.
- Will the 2026 FFIEC proposal change credit union ratings?
- If adopted, it would. The notice's NCUA section says the revisions would apply to all federally insured credit unions. As of November 6, 2026 no final action had been published; comments closed August 17, 2026.
Sources and further reading
- NCUA, CAMELS Rating System final rule, 86 FR 59282, October 27, 2021, effective April 1, 2022 (checked 2026-11-06)
- NCUA, Letter to Credit Unions 22-CU-05, CAMELS Rating System, March 2022
- NCUA, 22-CU-05 Appendix A, NCUA's CAMELS Rating System (revised)
- NCUA Examiner's Guide, CAMELS Ratings introduction, updated April 29, 2022
- NCUA Examiner's Guide, Composite Rating, updated April 29, 2022
- NCUA Examiner's Guide, Assigning a CAMELS Rating to the S Component, updated December 6, 2024
- NCUA Examiner's Guide, Commercial and Member Business Loans: Credit Risk Rating Systems, updated November 25, 2016
- NCUA, Supervisory Letter 06-01, Evaluating Earnings, August 2006
- 12 CFR 723.4, Commercial loan policy (via Cornell LII)
- 12 CFR 792.30 and 792.31, disclosure of exempt records (via Cornell LII)
- NCUA, Agencies Finalize Policy Statement on Commercial Real Estate Loan Accommodations and Workouts, June 29, 2023
- FFIEC, Uniform Financial Institutions Rating System, request for comment, 91 FR 29128, May 19, 2026, comments closed August 17, 2026 (checked 2026-11-06)
- OCC Bulletin 2026-22, Supervisory Ratings: Proposed Revisions to the Uniform Financial Institutions Rating System, May 19, 2026
- NCUA Office of General Counsel, Opinion 97-0951, Disclosure of NCUA examination reports, December 1997

Ian Group has served as Head of Customer Success at Prodeal since March 2018. He leads customer onboarding, training and platform adoption for lenders and commercial real estate firms, while contributing to the company's product strategy and roadmap. Before joining Prodeal, he practiced commercial real estate law in New York. He holds a JD from Albany Law School.
- NCUA exam preparation for commercial lendingThe quarter before an NCUA exam, step by step.
- NCUA examGlossary definition of the examination that produces CAMELS ratings.
- What is the NCUA Examiner's Guide?The commercial lending pages examiners work from.
- Commercial loan reviewHow independent credit risk review supports the Asset quality rating.
- Credit union business lending under NCUA rulesPart 723, the MBL cap and CRE concentration.
- DSCR calculatorRecompute coverage from current operating statements.