Compliance

Commercial loan review: the independent second look at every risk rating

Loan review at banks and credit unions under the 2020 interagency guidance: independence, frequency, sample scope, rating validation and board reporting.

Updated November 15, 2026 · 10 min read · By , Head of Customer Success
Flat editorial illustration of a row of loan file folders on a shelf with one folder open under a desk lamp and a magnifying glass

The short answer

Loan review, also called credit risk review, is the independent function at a bank or credit union that tests whether loans are rated accurately, underwritten to policy and documented properly. It samples the portfolio, validates risk ratings, finds problem loans early and reports to the board. The governing reference is the Interagency Guidance on Credit Risk Review Systems issued in May 2020 by the Federal Reserve, FDIC, NCUA and OCC.

It is not the annual review of a single loan, which the lender or portfolio manager performs. Loan review is the second look by people with no control over the loan. The guidance expects significant loans to be reviewed typically annually, a board-approved scope, and results reported to the board or a board committee quarterly.

What is loan review at a bank or credit union?

The 2020 guidance says the function may be called loan review, credit review or asset quality review, and its structure varies with size, complexity and risk profile. A larger institution may run a dedicated unit; a smaller one may use qualified staff, officers or directors independent of the credits. Some or all of it may go to a qualified third party.

Whatever the structure, the guidance lists what an effective system accomplishes.

  • Finds weak loans early
    Promptly identifies loans with actual and potential credit weaknesses.
  • Validates risk ratings
    Validates and, if needed, adjusts ratings, especially on loans with potential or well-defined weaknesses.
  • Spots portfolio trends
    Identifies trends and segments that are potential problem areas.
  • Tests policy and law
    Assesses adherence to credit policies, loan administration procedures and laws.
  • Evaluates lending staff
    Reviews the quality of loan approval, monitoring and risk assessment.
  • Informs the board and the allowance
    Gives the board an independent view of portfolio quality and management data for the allowance for credit losses.

How is loan review different from an annual review?

Both happen about once a year and both end in a risk rating, but they answer different questions. The annual review asks whether this borrower still carries the risk it had at approval. Loan review asks whether the institution's ratings, underwriting and administration can be trusted across the portfolio.

The annual review is part of the monitoring covered in what happens after a commercial loan closes. NCUA's Examiner's Guide expects those reviews as often as necessary but no less than once a year, with documented site visits, covenant compliance testing, updated collateral values and verified lien positions.

Annual (periodic) credit review vs independent loan review. Editorial comparison built from the 2020 interagency guidance and NCUA's Examiner's Guide
Annual review of a loanIndependent loan review
Who does itLender, portfolio manager or credit analystStaff, a department or a third party independent of the loan and its approval
Unit of workOne borrower relationshipA risk-based sample and portfolio segments
Main questionHas this credit's risk changed since approval?Are ratings, underwriting and administration reliable?
OutputUpdated analysis, covenant tests, reaffirmed or changed ratingFindings, rating changes, trend analysis and a report to the board
Reports toCredit administration and the lineThe board or a board committee
Typical cadenceAt least annually, often after year-end financialsSignificant loans typically annually, on renewal or more often when risk rises

What does the 2020 interagency guidance cover?

The Interagency Guidance on Credit Risk Review Systems was issued May 8, 2020 and published in the Federal Register on June 1, 2020 at 85 FR 33278. OCC Bulletin 2020-50 says it replaces Attachment 1, Loan Review Systems, of the 2006 Interagency Policy Statement on the Allowance for Loan and Lease Losses. It aligns with the safety and soundness standards that require a system for independent, ongoing credit risk review: 12 CFR part 30, Appendix A (OCC), part 208, Appendix D-1 (Federal Reserve), part 364, Appendix A (FDIC), and Part 723 for NCUA.

The guidance starts with a written credit risk review policy, reviewed and typically approved at least annually by the board or a board committee. It covers reviewer qualifications and independence; the frequency, scope and depth of reviews; review of findings and follow-up; and communication of results. Reviewers should know sound lending practice, the institution's own lending guidelines, and relevant laws and supervisory guidance.

Quarterly
How often loan review results typically go to the board or a board committee, and more often when material adverse trends appear

Federal Reserve, FDIC, NCUA and OCC, Interagency Guidance on Credit Risk Review Systems, May 2020, footnote 14

Who can perform loan review independently?

Independence means the reviewers do not have control over the loan and are not part of, or influenced by, the people who approved it. Smaller institutions may use an independent committee of outside directors, or officers and directors who did not originate or approve the credits and whose pay is not influenced by the ratings.

Reporting lines carry the independence. The guidance says it is prudent for the function to report directly to the board or a board committee, with senior management handling administrative matters only if that does not compromise independence. The board may outsource the work, but responsibility for a sound system stays with the board, and outsourcing to the external auditor may raise additional independence questions. Credit risk review is not meant to be performed by internal audit, though internal audit keeps the ability to audit it.

How often should commercial loans be reviewed?

The interagency guidance expects significant loans, loan products or groups of loans to be reviewed typically annually, on renewal, or more often when internal or external factors point to deteriorating credit quality. Key risk indicators and performance metrics can support changes to frequency and scope.

The rating side follows the same rhythm. The OCC's Comptroller's Handbook booklet Rating Credit Risk says all credits should receive a formal review at least annually, that large, new, higher risk pass and problem credits and complex credits should be reviewed more often, and that smaller performing credits may be reviewed as exceptions. NCUA's Examiner's Guide says much the same for credit unions, tying the annual review to receipt of year-end financial statements.

How do you choose the loan review sample?

The scope is risk-based and typically approved by the board or a board committee annually, or when significant interim changes are made. The sample should be representative of the portfolio and give reasonable assurance that deterioration or unfavorable trends are found. The guidance sets no coverage percentage; it says the function considers industry coverage standards consistent with the institution's size, complexity, loan types, risk profile and risk management practices. An effective scope typically includes:

  • Large loans
    Loans over a predetermined size.
  • Smaller and new loans
    A sufficient sample of smaller loans, new loans and new loan products.
  • Higher risk indicators
    Credits approved as exceptions to policy and other loans with higher risk signals.
  • Portfolio segments
    Segments with similar borrower, product or collateral risk, segments growing rapidly, and exposures from non-lending activities that also pose credit risk.
  • Troubled and changed loans
    Past due, nonaccrual, renewed and restructured loans, plus loans previously adversely classified or on the watch list.
  • Insiders and affiliates
    Loans to insiders, related parties and affiliates.
  • Concentrations
    Loans that form concentrations of credit risk or share common repayment factors. On a CRE book that can mean one property type, one sponsor or one submarket.

What does a reviewer test in each commercial file?

The guidance lists what a selected loan is evaluated for: credit quality, underwriting, borrower performance and repayment sources; reasonableness of assumptions; guarantor or sponsor creditworthiness; credit and collateral documentation; lien perfection; approvals; covenant adherence; compliance with policy and law; credit loss estimates and timely charge-offs; and risk rating accuracy.

On a commercial real estate loan the reviewer starts from the credit memo and asks whether its numbers still hold. Recomputing coverage from the latest rent roll and operating statement with a DSCR calculator shows quickly whether a pass rating is still supported.

Documentation and lien perfection are tested against the closed file, which is why the post-closing audit trail matters long after funding: a recorded mortgage, a filed UCC and a final title policy either sit in the file or become a finding.

How does loan review validate risk ratings?

The guidance calls accurate, timely ratings the foundation of credit risk review. Lending staff assign them; loan review tests them. Differences go through a pre-arranged process, which may include formal appeal or arbitration. If the reviewer finds credit quality lower, the lower rating typically prevails unless the line produces information that wins the reviewer's or arbiter's agreement.

A bank whose internal grades differ from the regulatory scale should keep documentation translating them; NCUA does not require credit unions to adopt a uniform classification system. The regulatory definitions, as quoted in the OCC's Rating Credit Risk booklet, are below. The guidance's watchlist typically includes these adverse grades, and examiners test them when scoring asset quality under NCUA CAMELS ratings or the bank equivalent.

Regulatory credit risk ratings, summarized from the OCC Comptroller's Handbook, Rating Credit Risk
RatingRegulatory definition, in shortSignals the booklet describes
PassNot covered by the adverse definitions; no formal regulatory definitionThe booklet expects some stratification of pass grades; larger banks generally need more
Special mentionPotential weaknesses that deserve management's close attention; not adversely classifiedAdverse operating trends, an ill-proportioned balance sheet, adverse market conditions, an ineffective loan agreement
SubstandardInadequately protected by the obligor's sound worth and paying capacity or the collateral; well-defined weakness; distinct possibility of some lossUnprofitable operations, inadequate debt service coverage, inadequate liquidity or marginal capitalization; repayment may depend on collateral
DoubtfulAll the weaknesses of substandard, with collection or liquidation in full highly questionable and improbableBorrower usually in default; loss deferred pending specific events; nonaccrual required
LossUncollectible and of so little value that carrying it as a bankable asset is not warrantedBorrower often bankrupt or out of business; recorded in the period it becomes uncollectible

What goes in the loan review report to the board?

Reviewers keep a list of loans and segments reviewed, the review date, and a summary analysis supporting each rating. Findings and planned corrective actions with time frames go to loan officers, managers and senior management, and deficiencies unresolved by their deadlines go promptly to senior management and the board.

The board report itself includes comparative trends in portfolio quality, adherence to policies, underwriting and risk identification quality, compliance with laws and regulations, and management's response to substantive criticism. The OCC booklet adds rating MIS: double downgrades, how long credits stay in one grade, the ratio of upgrades to downgrades, and rating changes by loan officer and line of business. Where banks and credit unions keep that tracking in workbooks, the Prodeal vs spreadsheets comparison looks at where a shared spreadsheet stops holding up as more people work from it.

What does NCUA expect from credit union loan review?

NCUA joined the 2020 guidance, and its commercial lending rule sets the floor. Under 12 CFR 723.4(g), the commercial loan policy must provide for periodic loan review sufficient for portfolio risk management, including a periodic reevaluation of collateral value and marketability, and a credit risk rating system with ratings assigned at inception and reviewed as often as the credit union's risk monitoring requires.

The Examiner's Guide page on commercial loan administration, updated October 14, 2021, calls independent loan review an important internal control. Credit unions generally use an independent third party, and the review does not replace the credit union's own periodic reviews. Its representative sample tests underwriting, compliance, rating accuracy, documentation, collections, problem loans and impairment analysis (the page still cites ASC 310-10-35 and ASC 450). Reviewers should report administratively and functionally to the board or a board-designated committee.

Examiners then validate ratings on a reasonable sample of commercial loans. When they find significant rating inaccuracies, the credit risk rating systems page tells them to look for root causes and decide whether to expand the sample. The NCUA Examiner's Guide post covers the exam pages, and how to pass a commercial loan exam covers the findings that recur.

Questions lenders ask

What is the difference between an annual review and a loan review?
An annual review is the lender's update of one borrower's financials, covenants and rating. Loan review is an independent function that samples the portfolio to test whether ratings and underwriting are reliable, and reports to the board.
What share of the portfolio should loan review cover?
The guidance sets no percentage. It calls for a risk-based scope, approved by the board annually, that is representative of the portfolio and considers industry coverage standards suited to the institution's size, complexity and risk profile.
Is loan review the same as internal audit?
No. The guidance says credit risk review is not intended to be performed by internal audit, though the two may coordinate and internal audit keeps the ability to audit the review function independently. Loan review should report directly to the board or a board committee.
What happens when loan review and the lender disagree on a rating?
The guidance expects a pre-arranged process for resolving differences. When the reviewer finds lower credit quality, the lower rating typically prevails unless the line provides information that wins the reviewer's or an arbiter's agreement.
Does NCUA require loan review for commercial loans?
12 CFR 723.4(g) requires periodic loan review and a credit risk rating system in the commercial loan policy, and the Examiner's Guide calls independent loan review an important internal control.
What do examiners do when risk ratings are wrong?
NCUA's Examiner's Guide tells examiners to determine the root causes of significant rating inaccuracies and decide whether to expand their loan sample, weighing the pattern and severity of the errors, the adequacy of the allowance and capital, and whether the errors distort portfolio reporting.
Ian Group, Head of Customer Success at Prodeal
Written by
· Head of Customer Success, Prodeal

Ian Group has served as Head of Customer Success at Prodeal since March 2018. He leads customer onboarding, training and platform adoption for lenders and commercial real estate firms, while contributing to the company's product strategy and roadmap. Before joining Prodeal, he practiced commercial real estate law in New York. He holds a JD from Albany Law School.

Keep reading
Ready when you are

See your deals in real time.

Send us one live deal. We will build the room on your own checklist.