
The short answer
Loan covenants are the promises a borrower makes in the loan agreement and must keep for the life of the loan. The FDIC's examination manual divides them broadly into financial and non-financial covenants. For working purposes on a commercial real estate loan, this post sorts them into six groups (an editorial grouping, not a regulatory one): financial ratio tests such as DSCR, debt yield and LTV; guarantor net worth and liquidity; affirmative covenants (things the borrower must do); negative covenants (things it must not do); reporting covenants; and cash management triggers.
What happens when a covenant is missed depends on how the agreement is drafted. Some failures are automatic events of default, others become defaults only after a notice and cure period, and some, such as a cash trap, change how the property's cash moves without being a default at all. The precise definitions decide whether a test passes, which is why the OCC says the income and expense definitions in coverage covenants should be clearly defined.
What are the different types of loan covenants?
The table maps each type to an example from a real loan document. The Fannie Mae examples come from the current Multifamily Loan and Security Agreement (Non-Recourse), Form 6001.NR (06-26). The CMBS examples come from the Wilshire Portfolio loan agreement, a $105 million fixed-rate loan made in December 2024 by Wells Fargo, Bank of America and JPMorgan, filed on EDGAR by Creative Media & Community Trust.
| Type | What it does | Example in a real document |
|---|---|---|
| Financial | Sets a ratio or amount the property or borrower must meet | Wilshire defines DSCR and debt yield; its Cash Management Agreement uses a DSCR trigger |
| Guarantor | Requires the guarantor to keep minimum net worth and liquidity | Wilshire guaranty: net worth of at least $105 million and liquid assets of at least $6 million |
| Affirmative | Requires an action, such as insuring or maintaining the property | Form 6001.NR insurance covenants: special causes of loss, business income and flood coverage |
| Negative | Prohibits an action, such as other debt, other business or transfers | Form 6001.NR single asset status: no other real property, no other business, no commingling |
| Reporting | Requires financial statements and rent rolls on a schedule | Form 6001.NR: quarterly operating statements within 45 days, annual statements within 120 days |
| Cash management | Redirects cash when a trigger is hit | Wilshire Section 9.2: in a Cash Trap Event Period, excess cash flow goes to a lender subaccount |
Which financial covenants do CRE loans use?
The OCC's Comptroller's Handbook, Commercial Real Estate Lending (version 2.0, March 2022), lists the appropriate financial covenants for income-producing CRE loans as debt yield, DSCR, LTV, LTC and borrower or guarantor minimum net worth or liquidity, and calls these the most common. A DSCR covenant sets a floor on cash flow relative to debt service. A debt yield test sets a floor on cash flow relative to the loan balance, so it ignores the interest rate and amortization.
The definitions matter more than the threshold. The Wilshire agreement measures DSCR as Adjusted Net Cash Flow divided by the interest due over the next twelve months, as of the last day of the prior month, and debt yield as Adjusted Net Cash Flow divided by the outstanding principal, as of the last day of the prior quarter. Lender's calculation of both is conclusive absent manifest error. The OCC handbook says that when loan documents contain debt service coverage covenants, the definitions of income and expenses should be clearly defined, and that covenant DSCR may differ from the DSCR used in underwriting. Run the covenant version from the agreement's definitions, not the credit memo's; a DSCR calculator is a quick check once the inputs are defined.
What are guarantor net worth and liquidity covenants?
On a non-recourse loan, the guarantor's balance sheet backs the carve-out guaranty, so the lender sets a floor under it. The Wilshire guaranty requires the guarantor to maintain a net worth of no less than $105 million and liquid assets of no less than $6 million, both measured excluding the value of the loan collateral. Both floors drop in proportion to any partial prepayment or partial defeasance.
The OCC handbook lists the borrower's or guarantor's minimum liquidity, net worth and debt to worth among appropriate covenants for construction and development loans too, alongside limits on additional debts, guarantees and liens and on distributions to owners before loan repayment. The test needs the guarantor's own statements, which is why reporting covenants reach the guarantor and not only the property. The glossary entry on sponsor liquidity covers how lenders read it.
What are affirmative covenants?
Affirmative covenants are the things the borrower must keep doing. In the Wilshire agreement they fill Article 4: maintain the borrower's existence, comply with applicable law, maintain the property, pay taxes and other charges, keep books and records, deliver estoppel certificates, manage leases, pay for labor and materials, and comply with seismic retrofit requirements specific to one of the buildings.
Fannie Mae's Form 6001.NR puts insurance among them. The borrower must keep the improvements insured against special causes of loss with business income and flood coverage, carry commercial general liability insurance, and carry builder's risk when completing repairs. Failing to keep the required insurance in force is listed in the same form as an automatic Event of Default, which shows that an affirmative covenant can carry the heaviest consequence.
What are negative covenants?
Negative covenants are the things the borrower must not do. Fannie Mae's single asset status covenant is a clear example: until the debt is paid, the borrower may not acquire other real property or assets, run any other business, commingle its funds, or take on material financial obligations beyond permitted equipment financing and ordinary trade payables.
Transfers are the other big group. The Wilshire agreement's Article 6 is titled No Sale or Encumbrance, with defined permitted equity transfers and total property transfers. Fannie Mae's form makes any Transfer not permitted by the loan documents an automatic Event of Default, which is how a due-on-sale clause works in practice on a commercial loan. Single purpose entity covenants in Article 5 of the Wilshire agreement add separateness requirements that support the non-consolidation opinion.
What reporting covenants are standard?
Reporting covenants feed every other test. The OCC handbook says loan covenants should require periodic financial information on the project, borrowing entities and guarantors, with frequency set by the property's stability: annual statements and rent rolls may be enough for a property with long leases, while lease-up or multi-tenant properties could warrant monthly, quarterly or semiannual information. The table compares two real schedules. The glossary entry on financial reporting requirements covers the deliverables in brief.
| Deliverable | Fannie Mae Form 6001.NR | Wilshire CMBS loan agreement, Section 4.12 |
|---|---|---|
| Quarterly operating statements | Within 45 days after quarters 1 to 3, year to date | Within 45 days after each quarter, certified by a Responsible Officer |
| Rent roll | Rent schedule within 45 days after quarters 1 to 3 and 120 days after year end | Certified rent rolls quarterly, within 45 days |
| Annual statements | Within 120 days after year end; balance sheet when requested | Audited annual statements within 90 days after fiscal year end |
| Budget | Not a standing quarterly item | Annual budget by December 15; lender approval right during a Cash Trap Event Period |
| Failure to deliver | Lender may require audited books at the borrower's expense after the cure period | Event of Default if a Required Financial Item is not delivered within 30 days after request |
How do cash management triggers work?
A cash management trigger is a covenant test that changes where money goes instead of declaring a default. In the Wilshire loan, Section 9.2 provides that during a Cash Trap Event Period all excess cash flow is deposited into an Excess Cash Flow Subaccount, as set out in the Cash Management Agreement, and Section 4.12 gives the lender a right to approve the annual budget during that period. The trigger thresholds sit in the Cash Management Agreement, which was not part of the filing, so they are not shown here.
The same agreement's general ban on prepayment carves out whatever the Cash Management Agreement allows in connection with a DSCR Trigger Event Cure, so the cure mechanics also live in that document. A cash sweep and a springing lockbox are the two mechanisms most of these triggers switch on.
What happens when a covenant is breached?
It depends on the tier the agreement assigns. Fannie Mae's Form 6001.NR has three. Automatic Events of Default include failure to pay, failure to keep insurance, breach of single asset status, a material misrepresentation, an unpermitted Transfer, a Bankruptcy Event, and acceleration by the holder of other debt secured by the property, a form of cross-default. Some defaults become Events of Default only if not cured within a period specified in the documents. Everything else becomes an Event of Default if it continues 30 days after written notice, extendable up to another 30 days if the borrower is diligently pursuing a cure, unless the lender needs to act immediately to avoid harm.
The Wilshire agreement is similar in structure with different numbers. Other monetary defaults cure within 10 days after notice and other defaults within 30 days, extendable while the borrower diligently cures, with the extension capped at 90 days unless the lender agrees to more. A curable, immaterial misrepresentation made in good faith gets 30 days plus up to 60 more. A failure to give notice under the transfer article has a 10 Business Day cure period. Once an Event of Default occurs, Fannie Mae's form lets the lender accelerate the whole balance, including any prepayment premium, and use its other remedies.
How do covenant waivers and amendments work?
A waiver excuses a specific breach; an amendment changes the covenant going forward. The loan documents protect the lender from waiving by accident. Fannie Mae's form says a waiver of one Event of Default, or forbearance in exercising a remedy, is not a waiver of any other, and that accepting a late or partial payment does not waive the right to prompt payment of the rest. Section 16.2 of the Wilshire agreement makes any waiver or amendment effective only in a writing signed by the party against whom it is enforced, and only for the specific instance and purpose given.
Examiners look at the pattern. Appendix F of the OCC's Rating Credit Risk handbook, excerpted from 1998 examiner guidance on credit underwriting, lists nonexistent, weak or waived covenants among structural weaknesses, and tells examiners to watch for covenants waived or renegotiated to accommodate a borrower's failure to meet the original standard. A forbearance agreement is the more formal tool when the lender agrees not to enforce for a period.
How do covenants get from the documents to the file?
Every covenant needs its definition, test date, threshold, source deliverable and consequence written down at closing. The commercial loan documentation guide shows where each sits in the loan agreement, guaranty and cash management agreement. Lenders that track these on a spreadsheet tend to lose the link between the covenant and its source clause, the trade-off covered in the Prodeal vs spreadsheets comparison.
The testing cycle itself, from collecting statements to recording results, is covered in the post on how lenders monitor loan covenants. Prepayment terms are covenants too: the post on defeasance vs yield maintenance covers what the borrower owes to leave early.
Questions lenders ask
- What are the three types of covenants?
- A common grouping is affirmative (must do), negative (must not do) and financial (ratios and amounts). The FDIC's examination manual uses two groups, financial and non-financial. On CRE loans, reporting, guarantor and cash management covenants are usually tracked as their own types.
- What is an example of a debt covenant?
- A minimum DSCR or debt yield test is the classic example. Another is a guarantor floor: the 2024 Wilshire Portfolio guaranty requires a net worth of at least $105 million and liquid assets of at least $6 million, excluding the loan collateral.
- Is a covenant breach always an event of default?
- No. Some breaches are automatic Events of Default, some become defaults only after a notice and cure period, and some trigger cash management instead. The loan agreement assigns each covenant to a tier, so read the default article with the covenant.
- What is a technical default?
- A breach of a non-payment term, such as a late financial statement or a missed ratio test, while payments stay current. It can still be an Event of Default under the agreement, which is why lenders document whether it was cured, waived or left open.
- How often are loan covenants tested?
- As often as the agreement says. The OCC handbook ties reporting frequency to the property's stability: annual statements may be enough for long-leased or stabilized multifamily properties, while lease-up or multi-tenant properties could warrant monthly, quarterly or semiannual information. The Wilshire definitions measure DSCR as of a month end and debt yield as of a quarter end.
- What is the difference between a covenant and a condition precedent?
- A condition precedent must be satisfied before the lender funds or takes a step, such as delivering a title policy before closing. A covenant is an ongoing promise that applies after funding, for the life of the loan.
- Who calculates covenant compliance?
- The agreement says. Borrowers deliver the statements, and some CMBS agreements, including the Wilshire loan, make the lender's calculation of DSCR and debt yield conclusive absent manifest error.
Sources and further reading
- OCC, Comptroller's Handbook, Commercial Real Estate Lending, version 2.0, March 2022 (checked 2026-11-06)
- OCC, Comptroller's Handbook, Rating Credit Risk, April 2001 (updated June 2017), Appendix F (checked 2026-11-06)
- FDIC, RMS Manual of Examination Policies, Section 3.2 Loans (05/23), Loan Covenants
- Fannie Mae, Multifamily Loan and Security Agreement (Non-Recourse), Form 6001.NR (06-26)
- SEC EDGAR, Creative Media & Community Trust 8-K, Dec 27, 2024 (Wilshire Portfolio loan and guaranty summary)
- SEC EDGAR, Wilshire Portfolio Loan Agreement (CMBS Fixed Rate), Exhibit 10.1, Dec 27, 2024

Patrick Janson leads enterprise sales and solution strategy at Prodeal. He served as Prodeal's Chief Operating Officer from 2017 to 2022 and returned in 2024 following his time as a Product Lead in Hines' Innovation Group. He brings more than 15 years of experience in commercial real estate finance and technology, having started his career in commercial real estate lending at Emerald Creek Capital. Patrick serves on the Mortgage Bankers Association's Technology Advisory Council, is a former Chairman of the Young Mortgage Bankers Association, and has been a guest speaker at Cornell and Columbia Universities.
- DSCR covenantThe most common financial covenant.
- Covenant complianceThe ongoing confirmation, defined.
- DSCR calculatorCheck a coverage test.
- The commercial loan documentation guideWhere covenants sit in the document set.
- How do lenders monitor loan covenants after closing?The testing cycle, step by step.
- Defeasance vs yield maintenanceThe prepayment terms in the same agreements.