Explainer

Defeasance vs yield maintenance: two ways to pay for leaving early

Defeasance vs yield maintenance for CRE lenders: both formulas, a worked example, the REMIC rule, who is involved, and agency and CMBS terms side by side.

Updated November 15, 2026 · 10 min read · By
Flat editorial illustration of a balance scale with bond certificates on one pan and coins on the other, a loan folder below

The short answer

Yield maintenance and defeasance both protect the holder of a fixed-rate loan when the borrower wants out early. With yield maintenance, the borrower pays off the loan plus a premium meant to replace the lender's lost interest, usually with a 1% floor. With defeasance, the loan is not paid off. The borrower buys government securities whose payments match the remaining loan payments, pledges them as substitute collateral, and the property is released from the lien. A successor borrower takes over the note.

The choice is set in the loan documents, not at payoff. CMBS loans held in a REMIC trust lean on defeasance because federal tax rules allow a lien release on that basis, but not within two years of the trust's startup day. Fannie Mae offers yield maintenance and declining premium schedules. Freddie Mac fixed-rate loans move from yield maintenance to a lockout and then defeasance once securitized. Both exits cost the most when Treasury yields sit well below the note rate.

How is yield maintenance calculated?

Each loan agreement defines its own formula. The two families lenders see most are the agency style and the CMBS style, and the one-line version found online (present value of remaining payments times the rate difference) misses the details that decide the number.

Fannie Mae's Standard Yield Maintenance schedule (Schedule 4, fixed rate, Form 6104.01) sets the premium as the greater of 1% of the principal prepaid, or the principal prepaid times the Fixed Rate minus the Yield Rate, times a present value factor of [1 minus (1 + r) to the power of minus n/12] divided by r. Here r is the Yield Rate and n is the months left to the Yield Maintenance Period End Date. The Yield Rate is interpolated from the Treasury constant maturities in Federal Reserve release H.15 on the 25th Business Day before prepayment, rounded to three decimals.

The CMBS-style formula in the December 2024 Wilshire Portfolio loan agreement, filed on EDGAR by Creative Media & Community Trust, discounts every remaining scheduled payment, with the balance assumed due on the Open Period Start Date. On an amortizing loan, those scheduled payments are the ones a commercial real estate loan calculator lays out from the rate, term and amortization. The discount rate is the yield on the actively traded Treasury maturing closest to the Open Period Start Date, divided by 12. The premium is the amount by which that present value exceeds the outstanding balance, with a 1% floor. The yield maintenance glossary entry covers the term in brief.

What does a yield maintenance example look like?

The inputs below are hypothetical. Take a $10,000,000 interest-only loan at a 6.00% fixed rate with exactly 60 months left to the end of the yield maintenance period (and, for the CMBS formula, to the open period), prepaid in full, with the relevant Treasury at 4.00%. Five years is a reported H.15 maturity, so the Fannie form needs no interpolation.

Under the agency formula, the factor is [1 minus 1.04 to the power of minus 5] divided by 0.04, or 4.4518, so the premium is $10,000,000 times 2.00% times 4.4518, about $890,364. Under the CMBS formula, 60 monthly payments of $50,000 and the $10,000,000 balance discounted at 4.00% divided by 12 are worth about $10,904,984, a premium of about $904,984. At a 7.00% Treasury, both premiums drop to the 1% floor of $100,000. For a real loan, lay out the interest-only payments and the balance due in a balloon payment calculator, which takes interest-only years and prints the schedule, then apply the note's definitions.

Hypothetical $10,000,000 interest-only loan, 6.00% fixed, 60 months left (illustration only, flat Treasury curve assumed)
Treasury yieldAgency-style premiumCMBS-style premiumIllustrative defeasance portfolio cost
4.00%About $890,364About $904,984About $10,904,984 before fees
7.00%$100,000 (1% floor)$100,000 (1% floor)About $9,579,150 before fees

How does defeasance work?

In defeasance the loan stays outstanding and the collateral changes. Section 2.8 of the Wilshire agreement shows the sequence. The borrower gives 30 to 90 days' notice of a Total Defeasance Date, pays everything due through that date, and deposits U.S. Obligations into a Defeasance Collateral Account. The agreement defines those as government securities under Section 2(a)(16) of the Investment Company Act of 1940 and Treasury Regulation 1.860G-2(a)(8), not callable or prepayable, paying on or just before each remaining payment date through the Open Period Start Date in at least the scheduled amounts.

The borrower signs a security agreement over the account and delivers a counsel opinion on the lender's perfected first priority interest, the trust's REMIC status and the absence of a significant modification, plus a new non-consolidation opinion. It also delivers any Rating Agency Confirmation the securitization requires, an officer's certificate, and a Big Four or other nationally recognized accounting firm's certificate that the securities cover the scheduled payments. A single purpose Successor Borrower, designated by the borrower and approved by the lender, then assumes the note for a payment of at least $1,000 and keeps any residual once the note is paid.

Why do CMBS loans use defeasance?

Because of the REMIC rules. Under 26 CFR 1.860G-2(a)(8), a mortgage held by a REMIC ceases to be a qualified mortgage on the date its lien is released, unless the release fits an exception. Defeasance is one, and all four conditions must be met: the borrower pledges substitute collateral consisting solely of government securities; the mortgage documents allow the substitution; the lien is released to facilitate the disposition of the property or any other customary commercial transaction, and not as part of an arrangement to collateralize a REMIC offering with obligations that are not real estate mortgages; and the release is not within two years of the startup day, the day the REMIC issues all of its regular and residual interests.

Loan agreements build the two-year rule in. Wilshire's Defeasance Lockout Release Date is the earlier of the third anniversary of the first payment date and two years after the startup day of the last REMIC trust holding any part of the loan. A payoff in full simply ends the mortgage, which is why many CMBS loans let the borrower choose either path after that date.

What does defeasance cost, and who is involved?

The main cost is the securities portfolio. Pensford, a rate advisory firm, describes the defeasance premium in its article Defeasance Without The Premium? as the portfolio's cost minus the outstanding principal balance: positive when Treasury yields are below the note rate, possibly negative when above. The documents put transaction costs on the borrower.

  • Borrower and its counsel
    Send the notice, buy the securities (or have them bought on the borrower's behalf) and deliver the opinions.
  • Lender or servicer and its counsel
    Review the collateral and prepare the security agreement and release. Both the Wilshire and 2019 Freddie Mac agreements charge these costs and rating agency fees to the borrower; Freddie's applies whether or not the defeasance closes.
  • Accounting firm
    Certifies that the portfolio's payments cover every scheduled payment.
  • Securities intermediary
    Holds the pledge. The 2019 Freddie Mac agreement requires book-entry facilities of a qualified intermediary the lender designates.
  • Processing fee
    The 2019 Freddie Mac agreement filed by Steadfast Income REIT requires a $10,000 non-refundable Defeasance Fee with the notice and a closing 30 to 60 days after it.

Which loans use defeasance or yield maintenance?

Read the note first: terms vary by lender and loan, and the table shows only what the named documents say. Balance sheet lenders write their own clauses. The commercial loan documentation guide shows where prepayment terms sit among the note, loan agreement and schedules.

Prepayment structures in the primary documents reviewed (checked 2026-11-06)
Loan typeStructure in the documentsSource
CMBS conduit, fixed rateNo voluntary payoff in full until the Defeasance Lockout Release Date. Then defease, or prepay in full with yield maintenance (1% floor), until the open period six months before maturityWilshire Portfolio loan agreement, Dec 2024
Fannie Mae fixed rateStandard yield maintenance (greater of 1% or formula), then 1% until the last day of the fourth month before the maturity month, then no premiumFannie Mae Form 6104.01 (05-20)
Fannie Mae declining premiumSet percentages by loan year, for example 5-5-4-4-3-3-2-2-1-1 on a 10-year fixed rate loanFannie Mae Declining Prepayment Premium term sheet, 2026
Freddie Mac fixed rateYield maintenance until securitized, then a 2-year lockout, then defeasance; no premium in the final 90 days. If not securitized within the first year, yield maintenance until the final 90 daysFreddie Mac Optigo Fixed-Rate Loans term sheet, April 2026
Floating rateSpread maintenance before the open prepayment date: spread times amount repaid times days left over 360Apartment Income REIT loan agreement, Sept 2024

How do Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac handle prepayment?

Fannie Mae calls yield maintenance a trusted option that preserves investor returns, and offers a declining premium for fixed rate, SARM and Hybrid ARM loans. For Hybrid ARM loans, Section 1203 of its Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide (effective October 26, 2026) allows a 5% declining schedule, a 3% declining schedule, or yield maintenance ending in the 5th, 7th or 10th loan year, with no premium on a casualty or condemnation prepayment. For Choice Refinance loans, which refinance a Fannie Mae portfolio loan, Section 1702 bars waiving any premium based on required yield maintenance.

Freddie Mac ties the structure to securitization. Its Optigo Fixed-Rate Loans term sheet (April 2026) sets a 2-year lockout after securitization, then defeasance, and offers yield maintenance without defeasance on securitized loans at an additional cost. The 2019 Freddie Mac agreement on EDGAR applies its defeasance section only if the note goes to a REMIC trust before the Cut-off Date and provides for defeasance. The Fannie Mae multifamily loan documents post shows where these schedules sit.

When can a borrower prepay without a premium?

Most fixed-rate loans end with an open window. In the Wilshire loan, the Open Period Start Date is the payment date in July 2029, six months before the January 11, 2030 maturity, and from then the loan may be prepaid in full without yield maintenance on 30 days' notice. Fannie Mae's fixed-rate schedule charges no premium from the last day of the fourth month before the maturity month. Freddie Mac's 2026 fixed-rate term sheet charges none in the final 90 days.

Before the window there may be a lockout period, when no prepayment is allowed at any price. Fannie Mae's declining premium term sheet shows a 2-year lockout on its 7-year fixed structure and none on the 10-year. A step-down prepayment schedule skips the formula: the loan year's percentage is the premium.

What should the lender's file hold for a payoff?

A payoff or defeasance is a small closing of its own. The file needs the prepayment schedule, the notice and its receipt date, the Treasury source and date, the calculation with each input, and for defeasance the security agreement, opinions, accountant's certificate, assumption agreement and recorded release. The terms often sit in the loan system of record while the documents move by email, the split the Prodeal vs nCino comparison discusses.

A successor borrower assumes the note, so its covenants still run to maturity. The post on commercial loan covenants covers those types, and the SASB vs conduit post covers how the securitization structure shapes them.

Questions lenders ask

What is the difference between spread maintenance and yield maintenance?
Yield maintenance compares the loan's fixed rate with a Treasury yield and discounts the lost interest. Spread maintenance, used on floating rate loans, charges the loan's spread on the amount repaid for the days left to a set date. The 2024 Apartment Income REIT loan agreement computes it as spread times amount repaid times days over 360.
What is the purpose of the defeasance clause in a commercial mortgage?
It gives the borrower a contractual right to release the property by substituting government securities, without paying off the loan. For a loan in a REMIC trust, 26 CFR 1.860G-2(a)(8) requires the mortgage documents to allow that substitution, so the right must be written into them.
What triggers a due-on-sale clause in a commercial loan?
Any transfer of the property or of controlling interests that the loan documents do not permit. Fannie Mae's Form 6001.NR makes such a Transfer an automatic Event of Default. The 2019 Freddie Mac agreement lists a compliant defeasance as a Permitted Transfer.
Can a lender waive yield maintenance?
On a balance sheet loan, the holder decides under its own documents. Fannie Mae's Guide Section 1702 bars waiving any premium based on required yield maintenance when a Fannie Mae portfolio loan is refinanced as a Choice Refinance loan, and allows waiving only the 1% minimum in set cases.
Is defeasance cheaper when interest rates rise?
Usually. When Treasury yields are above the note rate, the securities cost less than the loan balance, while yield maintenance falls to its floor, often 1% of principal. The floor can then make yield maintenance the more expensive exit.
Can a loan be partially defeased?
Only if the documents say so. The Wilshire loan allows partial defeasance on an arm's length sale of two named properties, with the defeased note sized at the greatest of 115% of the allocated loan amount, 100% of net sales proceeds and the amount REMIC rules require.
Patrick H. Janson, Prodeal
Written by
· Prodeal

Patrick Janson leads enterprise sales and solution strategy at Prodeal. He served as Prodeal's Chief Operating Officer from 2017 to 2022 and returned in 2024 following his time as a Product Lead in Hines' Innovation Group. He brings more than 15 years of experience in commercial real estate finance and technology, having started his career in commercial real estate lending at Emerald Creek Capital. Patrick serves on the Mortgage Bankers Association's Technology Advisory Council, is a former Chairman of the Young Mortgage Bankers Association, and has been a guest speaker at Cornell and Columbia Universities.

Keep reading
Ready when you are

See your deals in real time.

Send us one live deal. We will build the room on your own checklist.